American Idol - Final 12

[AmandaDi]

So what are y'alls thoughts?! Are you pleased with the top 12?

I was pretty upset to see Nikko go, but otherwise I am really happy with the final 12!

[GnawtyAngel]

Yep, I'm pretty happy with the top 12!

[Chrisanne]

Seeing Nikko goes was kinda upsetting, he really is good. And I wasn't to thrilled with Mikayla (or however its spelled). Its gonna be a good competition.

Thank god Janay is gone.

[Tiatrack]

I like the top 12. I ditto Chrisanne...I really didn't think Janay was good AT ALL! I'm still rooting for Carrie Underwood, although I like the mail carrier girl too. I don't know too much about the men because I'm in class on Monday nights.

[MistyMeanor]

I am so ticked Nikko got voted off! He was consistant every week and had a wonderful style and voice! Constantine should have gone! He's ugly when he sings, and his pitch is off all across the board!

I wasn't disappointed with Amanda going cause she needed to. But Makayla needed to go FIRST. She's friggen Fran Dreschers (The Nanny) daughter I swear!

Another look alike with his hat on is Mario. Is he not Fez (Wilmer Vanderwahl sp?) from That 70's show or what?!! lmao!

[tonib809]

LOL, I love Mario!! I think Mikayla should have left & Nikko shouldve stayed.... but the rest are a good top 12!!

[AmandaDi]

ET just said that Mario quit! Somthing to do with the contracts they wanted him to sign... Nikko will be replacing him in the top 12.

[Chrisanne]

WOW!! Maybe he got a better offer already.

[Janice]

I am SO GLAD that Nikko is back! Ian and I pitched a FIT when he was voted off. I agree constantine should be gone, the only reason he is around is because "the women like him" - NOT ME! I think he's skeezy looking. :puke:

I honestly can't think of one female that stands out to me as a STAR. The females this year are just ... average?

[Chrisanne]

Ok, so this week was a big joke. LOL!! Can't wait to see who goes home. I so hope its Mikayla.

Randy said Nikko "was the best preformer of the whole show" .... I like Nikko, but i SO beg to differ.

[AmandaDi]

I hope she goes home too! I think Nikko did great, but I have to say Carrie or Jessica did the best.

[haleybobl]

I so hope its Mikayla.


I've thought that EVERY week from the start. I totally agree! :tup:

[MistyMeanor]

Ditto that! She drives me looney and IMO has no business being in the top 12!
Another one that I don't think deserves to be there is Constantine. Blech! WTF?! "I Think I Love You" by the Partridge Family!!!! OMG I wanted to BARF!

I am glad to see Carrie Underwood branching from her country songs. She totally kicked butt on Hearts' Alone. I really felt it was a wise choice to keep her in as I felt doing only country could have been to her detriment if she didn't change it up and show her versatality.

Since last night, my top picks are Carrie, Jessica, Nikko, Bo, and Scott.

[Chrisanne]

Another one that I don't think deserves to be there is Constantine. Blech! WTF?! "I Think I Love You" by the Partridge Family!!!! OMG I wanted to BARF!


OMG you took the words right out of my mouth. I laughed through that WHOLE song.

Bo did really good, even though the judges didn't seem impressed. That was a hard song to do.

[haleybobl]

So, I was out of the house tonight and miss who got voted off...any help would be great!

[Tiatrack]

No big surprise...Mikayla. Final three were Afro woman and geeky blonde guy (can you tell I'm bad with names?!).

[AmandaDi]

lol bottom 3 were Mikayla, Nadia and Anthony. Bottom two were Mikayla and Nadia... Mikayla got the boot! Thank goodness!

[GnawtyAngel]

I'm so happy Mikayla is finally gone!

[Chrisanne]

I can't believe Jessica got sent home. SO sad. It so should have been Nadia

[MistyMeanor]

Really?! I thought it should have been Anwar.

Regardless I thought two of them should have been replaced with Anthony and Constantine.

[Chrisanne]

I sooo hope its Nadia next week, I can't stand her.

Its sad to see that one of the best get eliminated.

[Tiatrack]

I fell asleep before it came on (I got a cold from the 5 flights I took over the weekend!), but I was shocked to hear on the radio that Jessica got voted off. She was one of my favorites. Who were the other bottom two?

[Chrisanne]

nadia and anwar were the other bottom two. Nadia was the one who had the highest votes of the three.

While I think each weeks performance is important I prefer to vote on all perfomances as a whole. If I were to pick based on all the performances... Constantine or Nadia should be gone.

[AmandaDi]

I too think it should have been Nadia. She is a GREAT performer, but she just doesnt have the vocals and the range that Jessica had.

BooHoo

Its getting hard to pick who I want to see go!

[paris26]

I thought it would have been Anthony. I'm rooting for Bo and Carrie :)